Over the weekend, the PHP project learned that its git server had been compromised. Attackers inserted malicious code into the repo. This is very bad. As a result, the project moved development to GitHub.
It’s easy to say that open source projects should run their own infrastructure. It’s harder to do that successfully. The challenges compound when you add in writing the infrastructure applications.
I understand the appeal. It’s zero-price (to write; you still need the hardware to run it). Bespoke software meets your needs exactly. And it can be a fun diversion from the main thing you’re working on: who doesn’t like going to chase a shiny for a little bit?
Of course, there’s always the matter of “the thing you wanted didn’t exist when you started the project.” PHP’s first release predates the launch of GitHub by 13 years. It’s 10 years older than git, even.
Of course, this means that at some point PHP moved from some other version control system to Git. That also means they could have moved from their homegrown platform to GitHub. I understand why they’d want to avoid the pain of making that switch, but sometimes it’s worthwhile.
Writing secure and reliable infrastructure is hard. For most projects, the effort and risk of writing their own tooling isn’t worth the benefit. If the core mission of your project isn’t the production of infrastructure applications, don’t write it.
The question of whether or not to write your infrastructure applications is different from the question of whether or not to self-host. While the former has a pretty easy answer of “no”, the latter is mixed. Self-hosting still costs time and resources, but it allows for customization and integration that might be difficult with software-as-a-service. It also avoids being at the whims of a third party who may or may not share your project’s values. But in general, projects should do the minimum that they can reasonably justify. Sometimes that means running your own instances of an infrastructure application. Very rarely does it mean writing a bespoke infrastructure application.